Skip to content
FREE SHIPPING – Orders over $34 (Domestic retail only)
    • Heartbeat Animals
    • Gender Reveal
    • Accessories
    • Ultrasound Gifts
    • Supplies
    • Pet Keepsakes
    • Bargain Cave
    • New Arrivals
    • Digital Marketing
    • See All Products
  • Store Locator
  • Wholesale Program
  • Blog
    • Contact Us
    • FAQs
    • Media
    • Shipping & Returns
  • Log in
  • instagram Instagram
  • Facebook
  • YouTube
  • X
  • Pinterest
  • TikTok
Cart
Subtotal
$0.00
Shipping, taxes, and discount codes calculated at checkout.
Your cart is currently empty.
  • Shop
    Heartbeat Animals
    Pet Keepsakes
    Gender Reveal Supplies
    Accessories
    Ultrasound Gifts
    New Arrivals
  • Store Locator
  • Wholesale Program
  • Blog
  • Contact & Support
    Heartbeat Animals
    Pet Keepsakes
    Gender Reveal Supplies
    Accessories
    Ultrasound Gifts
    New Arrivals

    Support

    • Contact Us
    • FAQs
    • Media
    • Shipping & Returns

    Our Warehouse

    ADDRESS
    303 E Ayre St, Wilmington, DE 19804

    info@mybabysheartbeatbear.com
    302-918-7663

    OPENING HOURS

    Mon - Fri: 9am - 4 pm
account Log in icon-search Search icon-bag-minimalCart
Access Denied
IMPORTANT! If you’re a store owner, please make sure you have Customer accounts enabled in your Store Admin, as you have customer based locks set up with EasyLockdown app. Enable Customer Accounts
Home / Blog / Tooth Fairy 101: When the fairy does not show.
Child
no tooth fairy
Parenthood
tooth fairy
tooth fairy help
tooth fairy ideas
what to do when the tooth fairy doesn't come

Tooth Fairy 101: When the fairy does not show.

Elizabeth MacDonald

May 13, 2019
by Elizabeth MacDonald
Tooth Fairy 101: When the fairy does not show.

Did you know that some parents are dipping $5 bills (and coins) in glitter, and hanging miniature doll house doors on the wall for the Tooth Fairy to enter through? There is fairy dust, tiny fairy footprints, even tiny letters you can create to keep your child believing.

Thanks to Pinterest, moms everywhere feel the need to up their Tooth Fairy game.

Generations ago, baby teeth were buried in gardens to prevent witches from stealing them and curses being placed on the children who lost the teeth. It was also believed that planting the teeth aided in the growth of the permanent teeth. By the 1920’s, families had transitioned to pillows instead of flower pots; they included gifts in exchange for the teeth.

Today, most families still utilize the under-the-pillow method, and most often, they opt for money as the gift for exchange. Whether the exchange is Pinterest-worthy or not, that is up to each family.

But wait... What if the Tooth Fairy flat out forgets to show up? What if your child wakes up in the morning devastated that her tooth is still there?

It can be quite hard to think on your toes in a moment like this, so we've created a list of amazing excuses as to why that little fairy missed your house. Don't worry, they'll keep your child believing.

When The Tooth Fairy Does Not Show

The younger the child, the easier it is to pull off these tiny white lies.

fairy

  1. She was running low on fairy dust and couldn’t make the flight.
  2. She heard you waking up and had to disappear fast.
  3. She got lost.
  4. She may have a cold – or the fairy pox.
  5. There was inclement weather leaving Baton Rouge and she had to stop for the night.
  6. She sent you a snap chat saying she was on vacation.
  7. You forgot that yesterday was the Tooth Fairy’s birthday! She must have had a surprise party.
  8. Too many children lost a tooth yesterday and she couldn’t carry them all.
  9. She’s trying new hours, and she’ll be by when you aren’t looking today!
  10. There was a fairy wedding last night and she got to throw fairy dust all over the bride and groom.
  11. She ran out of money and the fairy bank was closed for night.
  12. It was a full moon and fairies go swimming and celebrate all night every time there is a full moon.
  13. There could be a fairy strike because kids aren’t brushing their teeth well enough.
  14. Her best friend invited her over for a sleepover; she’ll be back to work tonight.
  15. Maybe the Tooth Fairy has been working really, really, really hard lately. Her schedule is overflowing and she is just off her game. Maybe she just forgot.

To Keep the Tooth or Toss it?

Do you stockpile your kids' baby teeth? Do you drop them in the kitchen trash? While most parents opt to trash the teeth, quite a few hold on them. (Why? Sentimental value? We aren't quite sure.)

If you are on the fence about keeping or tossing the teeth, you may be interested in this:

Some people are actually paying to store their children’s teeth.

Like the umbilical cord, there are precious stem cells inside of these teeth. While science has not figured out just what to do with these cells, it seems true that they may be precious commodity. Prices can range from $850 to $1,750 with annual storage fees averaging $120.

While this may seem extreme, maybe it's better than storing those teeth in your sock drawer for the next 20 years.

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Subscribe to our newsletter and receive our articles & discounts.
Vintage Giraffe

Vintage Giraffe

wholesale-cta_600x600_30ffe1f1-22dd-4d5c-9b4f-0fe47d46626e

Featured Articles

Healthy and Delicious Pumpkin Recipes for Pregnancy

Healthy and Delicious Pumpkin Recipes for Pregnancy

October 03, 2025
Bridging the Gap Between Pet Loss and Healing

Bridging the Gap Between Pet Loss and Healing

October 01, 2025
Pumpkin Spice & Pregnancy – Making Autumn Ultrasounds Unforgettable

Pumpkin Spice & Pregnancy – Making Autumn Ultrasounds Unforgettable

September 29, 2025
Fall-Inspired Gender Reveal Bundles

Fall-Inspired Gender Reveal Bundles

September 24, 2025
Share Share on Facebook Share Tweet on X Pin it Pin on Pinterest

icon-left-arrow Back to Blog

Similar Articles

How to Stay in Love After Having a Baby

How to Stay in Love After Having a Baby

Valentine Crafts for Toddlers' Fine Motor Skills

Valentine Crafts for Toddlers' Fine Motor Skills

5 Ways to Help Ease Preschool Anxiety

5 Ways to Help Ease Preschool Anxiety

What Your Baby's Zodiac Sign Means

What Your Baby's Zodiac Sign Means

Invalid password
Enter
★★★★★

I just wanted to say THANK YOU! I love your products and the shipping is always fast. Also, thank you for all the extras you send with the shipments. The quality of your items is always the best! Thank you!

Tom Costas

4/10/2025

★★★★★

Totally recommend 100% great gifts and customer service is amazing. Thank you so much Breann for assisting me! I got my grandmother the angel bear singing happy birthday from her mother who passed away last year. She would always call and sing happy birthday to all her children, grandchildren, and great grandchildren. ALL of them. Never missed one. And this helped her to still have that last year and many years to come.

Kayla

3/15/2023

★★★★★

Where to begin. My son Davin was stillborn last year and I was for fortunate enough to have had his heart beat recorded. I found healing in taking My Heartbeat Bear animals and adding weight to them for other bereaved parents to have something special to hold and cuddle. I’ve since started a non profit called Our Baby’s Legacy for pregnancy and infant loss support, and these weighted animals are a big part of what we do.
The product My Baby Heartbeat Bear makes is really great quality, which is extra important for me considering they may become some parents most cherished possessions after their loss. The animals are super soft and I absolutely love the vintage design where they are floppy and cuddly, and just the perfect size. I also love that there are so many choices, I’m always touched by why one parent chooses one over the other. Seems like a small feature, but to be able to choose a cow because thief nursery was to be barnyard themed, or a bunny bc their baby was born in the spring, is something very special.
I also have found working with the company to be a wonderful experience. Sheldon is who interact with most. When first setting up my account he offered a free sample and has since sent me samples of other items by them. I’ve had to call and add last minute animals to my order or request they be processed ASAP and he and the other staff have always been very accommodating.
I can’t say enough about how easy they make my job. they don’t likely know it but they are making a massively positive impact in the bereavement community with these animals through Our Baby’s Legacy. The animals bring light and comfort into the lives of an otherwise dark and broken place.

Sarah

10/22/2019

★★★★★

I own at 3D ultrasound studio in Myrtle Beach SC and everyone LOVES this heartbeat buddies! They are so soft and cuddly and I love all of the vintage inspired ones. Thanks so much for such a great product for my expectant mamas!

Whitney

7/17/2019

★★★★★

I ordered the gender reveal "egg" frame for my daughter and her husband to use this past weekend and everyone just LOVED it! Everything in the shop is just AWESOME! I have a feeling I'll be ordering more things very soon. Thanks so much.

Toni

4/10/2019

★★★★★

I love my pink bear. 💜 it have it on display in my daughter's room. she loves listening to her heart heart from when I was carrying her 5 years ago.

Brianda

1/16/2019

Subscribe and Save!

Receive updates, access to exclusive deals, and more!

Featured On

Shop

  • My Baby’s Heartbeat Bear
  • My Angel’s Heartbeat Bear
  • My Furbaby’s Heartbeat Bear
  • Gender Reveal Gifts

Support

  • Search
  • Contact Us
  • FAQs
  • For Wholesalers
  • Shipping & Returns

Find Out More

  • Store Locator
  • Become a Wholesaler
  • Login
  • Blog
  • About Us

Download Our App

Record your baby’s heartbeat with our app for safekeeping

FIND OUT MORE

  • instagram Instagram
  • Facebook
  • YouTube
  • X
  • Pinterest
  • TikTok
  • American Express
  • Apple Pay
  • Diners Club
  • Discover
  • Google Pay
  • JCB
  • Mastercard
  • PayPal
  • Venmo
  • Visa
© 2025 My Baby's Heartbeat Bear Policy / Terms & Conditions
Tooth Fairy 101: When the fairy does not show. - My Baby's Heartbeat Bear

Join our Hospital Wholesale Program

We’ll help you transform patient experiences with compassion. Just fill out this brief form.